Lessons Learned at LCR’s MID Candidate Forum
By Emerson Drake
The Latino Community Roundtable (LCR) conducted a flawless MID candidate forum for the public Monday night. They
adhered to their rules which include: only those with paid memberships can vote, those with both personal and business memberships can vote twice, and it’s allowable to come prior to the forum and place your votes and leave before the forum starts. About 50 people were present if you include the eight candidates. I was present as the votes were counted and the process went off without a hitch as has been my experience with LCR. The eight candidates all responded to the questions put to them to the best of their ability. Quite honestly there was a wide discrepancy in their ability and afterward I wondered if those voting were at the same forum I was, but that is just my personal opinion. All in all It was a fair democratic process.
And now the vote totals:
MID District 2 John Mensinger 23 Carmen Sabatino 3
MID District 3 Paul Campbell 18 Les Johnson 7
MID District 4 Jim Mortensen 15 Jake Wenger 9 Ted Donham 1 Brad Johnson 0
What I learned at the Forum
As an observer and participant of the political process I’ve been aware of a slate of candidates being run by Bill Lyons. In recent MID elections Mr. Lyons has supported the majority of candidates to the tune of $5,000 each. Unfortunately he supported the candidates who, in turn, supported former General Manager Allen Short. Short consistently made some of the worst decisions possible costing MID ratepayers millions of dollars. He was also behind the creation of the slush fund where the MID Board funneled $249,000 through Martino Graphics to a variety of lobbyists. The man receiving the most money was a political consultant named Mike Lynch. Would it surprise anyone to learn Mr. Lynch is the major consultant behind Lyons candidate slate? With Mike Lynch having the MID money pie all over his face it’s understandable for Bill Lyons to bring in someone unconnected with the Martino Graphics fiasco to be the slate’s (Mortensen, Mensinger, and Campbell) public consultant.
The high profile political consultant is Chip Langman of Langman Consulting. In a conversation with Mr. Langman he stated he was representing and being paid by candidates Mensinger and Campbell and denied being part of the Mortensen campaign. I suppose when campaign consultants are talking with those who might write about the conversation it’s understandable that being forthcoming (honest) might not be first on their agenda and unfortunately this was the case with Mr. Langman. Jim Mortensen had previously let it slip, that while he didn’t have a contract with Langman Consulting directly, his major benefactor, Bill Lyons did and it was on his behalf along with that of the other two candidates.
Both John Mensinger and Paul Campbell seem to be nice men in their own right. This is part of the Bill Lyons technique (modus operandi seemed a little too fancy, but applicable). Lyons likes to bring in respectable businessmen that have little or no experience to run for MID like Glen Wild. Their main value? To vote as they are told. They have little to no experience with MID’s water and electrical issues seeing that Mensinger just started coming to meetings recently and Campbell might not have even located the the MID Board room more than once. In the past both men have made public statements regarding the need to sell our water to San Francisco.
Jim Mortensen is a horse of a different color. He came to the podium during the water sale talks and was adamant about wanting MID to sell water on a long term basis to San Francisco. And he stuck to his opinion when all of the details of the reprehensible contract came to light. To make a mistake and be wrong and then change your mind is one thing, but to continue on the road to ruin is another. He continues to say we need to monetize our water. Just a week ago Mortensen came out publicly for the Board Governance policy which restricts the elected Directors access to the very information necessary to make informed decisions, thereby forcing them to rely solely on staff opinions without being able evaluate the facts for themselves. This rule made it easier for Allen Short to bamboozle the Board into terrible costly decisions, decisions we ratepayers are still paying for (if you have any doubt check your electric bills). Mortensen had pledged he would NOT use the Water Advisory Board as a jumping off point to run for office but he did. Mortensen’s track record tell us he either lies to his advantage or makes terrible decisions and refuses to correct them.
Please understand Bill Lyons has been behind the proposed MID water sale to San Francisco all along. He doesn’t care if we run out of water since his property is along the river and he knows his 11 deep wells will bring him a fortune if the water runs out and everyone become desperate. In my opinion he wants to assist in our destruction so he can make a fortune. He can’t dam the water up so he wants to facilitate the sale of it out from underneath us. Even during droughts San Francisco was going to get their water first and MID, you and I, were going to get the leftovers.
Also know this isn’t Lyons first rodeo. Four years ago Lyons personally supported Glen Wild’s and Paul Warda’s campaigns to the tune of $5,000 each and had his cronies do the same for Tom VanGroningen. Team Lyons has pledged to raise $60,000 for Mortensen’s campaign. In the past he supported John Kidd and Cecil Hendsley’s campaigns too. Lyons likes to play behind the scenes and stack the deck with jokers. Please know several people who helped to recruit Mensinger, Campbell and Mortensen were directly involved with MID in the last few years. These include Janice Keating through the Martino Graphics slush fund and George Petrulakis who was paid $28,000 to facilitate ONE meeting between MID and the City of Modesto. It isn’t a stretch to suggest this money, Keating’s and Petrulakis’, were down payments for services ‘to be rendered.’
We have many good candidates to choose from running for the Modesto Irrigation District and no offense to anyone, but none will be endorsed by the Latino Community Roundtable. Now you know the Bill Lyons and MID back story. Tell your friends, co-workers, and neighbors. The only way we can save our drinking water and keep our electric bills down is to make sure the Lyon’s slate of candidates doesn’t get into office.
Thanks Emerson, that was insightful. I got too busy to keep going to the MID meetings, but that has to be the worst run public agency I have ever set eyes on, and the ratepayers are getting stuck every which way.
I had no idea what was going on in Modesto until I saw some Mensinger for MID board signs and said to myself, “Here we go again. Long time prominent name from and old Modesto political and business family, so I know the ratepayers are going to get screwed again.” I don’t know why the electorate keeps voting for the same people, the same families, the same business leaders, to all our governmental positions, when all we get are higher bills and poorer service. This area is one of the poorest in the entire USA, yet we have hire rates for utilities & services and poorer service than some of the richest areas of the country
(see Santa Clara County Public Utility District rates for one: meter charge $2.5/month vs $12.50 for MID, Rate per KW, $.08 versus $0.16. NO you didn’t read that wrong, Silicon Valley is over half of our rate with a medium household income of $74K versus Stanislaus medium household income $20K)
I’ll check back in to see more about the candidates later.